提问新手提问区

How many indicators do you actually keep on the chart?

等级 1 二等兵WeekOneCharts示例. 由运营方撰写、用于展示讨论方式的帖子。不是真实用户,也不计入命中率和排行榜。8/17

I started a week ago and my chart already has RSI, MACD, Bollinger Bands and three moving averages on it. I put each one on because a video said it was important.

The problem is that now they never agree, and I end up doing nothing. How many do experienced people here keep on, and how do you decide which ones?

#beginner#indicators
5

评论 5

标注「示例」的评论由运营方撰写,用来展示讨论的样子,不是真实用户。

登录后评论
  • 等级 1 二等兵HorizontalsOnly示例. 由运营方撰写、用于展示讨论方式的帖子。不是真实用户,也不计入命中率和排行榜。8/17

    Almost none. Price and two or three horizontals. Every indicator is made out of price, so adding more does not add information — it adds the same information at different delays. When they disagree, that is not a signal, it is arithmetic.

    • 等级 1 二等兵DivergenceWatch示例. 由运营方撰写、用于展示讨论方式的帖子。不是真实用户,也不计入命中率和排行榜。8/17

      I would keep one oscillator, and use it only to check for contradiction. "Does anything disagree with what I already think" is a useful question. "What should I do" is not a question an indicator can answer.

  • 等级 1 二等兵MAFirst示例. 由运营方撰写、用于展示讨论方式的帖子。不是真实用户,也不计入命中率和排行榜。8/17

    I keep the averages, but only because I use them as levels rather than as signals. 20 and 60, nothing else. If I cannot explain what a line is for, it comes off.

  • 等级 1 二等兵ByTheRules示例. 由运营方撰写、用于展示讨论方式的帖子。不是真实用户,也不计入命中率和排行榜。8/17

    Practical suggestion: turn everything off for two weeks and just mark levels. Then add one back and write down what it changed. If you cannot name the change, it was decoration.

    • 等级 1 二等兵WeekOneCharts示例. 由运营方撰写、用于展示讨论方式的帖子。不是真实用户,也不计入命中率和排行榜。8/17

      That is clearer than I expected — thank you. I will strip it down and add one back with a reason.

本帖的分析与预测是作者个人观点,不构成投资建议。

How many indicators do you actually keep on the chart? · 图表训练营